Tao vs Sami
Sami says: A few days ago, Tao asked me for my opinion on Live Earth. She was writing a post on the event, and wanted to include some different perspectives. The post came and went, but as I hadn’t seen Live Earth, and was at best a little skeptical, it was difficult to comment. My initial thought was to write something on why I hadn’t bothered watching the show, but Tao was none too impressed by this approach. The resulting email exchange threw up some interesting issues, and we thought we would share an edited version with the world. It went something like this:
TAO: I ended up wholly inspired and impressed with the Live Earth broadcast last night! This COULD have a huge impact, after all! If you get a chance, Sami, could you watch and send me some thoughts for the blog?
SG: I’ll try and sit down and watch some, but I may not get a chance. Here’s my thoughts at this point:
I think it should be judged solely on how successful, or unsuccessful, was it in terms of moving us towards solutions to this massive crisis. Unfortunately, I find that hard to judge as I did not watch any of it. I guess that’s what worries me the most - despite, or perhaps because of, all the hype, I was left totally uninterested in seeing it.
The idea of so many celebrity musicians, only a few of whom I’d choose to watch at any other time, playing yet another ‘concert with a cause’ just seemed a little old fashioned and boring. What next, the climate change ribbon?
TAO: I had my skepticism, too, but realized it was not realistic to make any judgment until I actually saw it. [Ouch! Sami receives a severe blow from TAO’s ever sharp observations] And, what I saw greatly pleased and surprised me. It was not boring and it was not just another concert. They did spots between all performances, interviewing artists about their green habits and what changes they
were making. There were also brilliantly designed graphics detailing conservation tips. Really smart stuff!
SG: I guess I thought it was kind of relevant that the very idea turned me, and a lot of people, off before even seeing it. However well a concert is actually staged, if the audience isn’t inspired to watch, they’ll never know. If a tree falls in the woods…
[At this point Sami grumbles in resignation, if it’s possible to grumble by email, and agrees to watch some of the highlights]
TAO: From a marketing perspective, it is useful to notice why the “hype”
gave that first impression to you, me and some others, but I recognize
that humans - myself included - find it easier to simply go with first
impressions, and being cynical is sometimes sorta fun…..or, we like to
be on a “side” of an issue from the start, rather than do the analytical work.
[One day later...]
SG: Have just sat down and watched some of the show. I must say it looked pretty much like I expected. I’m still not against it, I just can’t really relate to it on any level other than it being a big celebrity ego trip/ hug fest. Madonna singing ‘Hey You’, with some of the most banal lyrics I have heard, somehow it all just seemed so shallow to me. And Boris Becker (??!!!) lecturing me on recycling - the less said about that the better!
I’m glad to hear that it affected you differently, and I really genuinely hope it will prove to wake a bunch of people up. I must admit that the info clips were helpful and interesting, and did transcend empty platitudes. I just also have a fear that the whole thing may help slot climate change in a convenient bubble of ‘just another issue’, rather than it being THE biggest threat to our existence. Didn’t we ‘do climate change’ last year? Spinal Tap was cool though.
TAO: I can’t disagree with your take on the what could be called “hype” at this kind of thing. Was it shallow? In some ways, yes! Was it ego-fueled? You bet. Was it a celebrity/groupie hug fest? Sure…
BUT, I wasn’t looking to be impressed and inspired myself as much as I was looking at it from an ipod/celebrity/Hollywood-obsessed, consumer-driven mainstream perspective and I do believe it was a successful campaign towards that end. Madonna is many things, but I wouldn’t call her or her lyrics shallow. In fact, she’s consistently explored controversial issues outside herself from racism to sexual identity to mysticism through both her music and her own life. And, well, anyone - even Boris Becker, who is willing to go on national television and talk about any green habit gets points in my book.
I don’t agree that this televised event will reduce the importance of this issue. I think it was done in a way that did transcend the green washing vibe that is out there in some mainstream places. And the fact that this was the first event of this sort that was truly and radically global will mark it in history and keep the climate change issue “on the front lines”.
At this point, Tao and Sami decided to agree to (kind of) disagree, post some of the exchange on the blog and invite others to join in the discussion. How do you feel about the Live Earth concert and its ongoing campaign to stop global warming? Let us know!